Nuevobasso

music tech blog

WordPress.com versus the new Blogger

Earlier this week Blogger unveiled its new Beta version. I have been playing with this service and am extremely happy with the new features Blogger is unveiling. Blogger, originally created by Pyra Labs was one of the pivotal fores n the explosion of the blogosphere over the last several years. Originally a tiered service with free and paid versions, Blogger was acquired by Google in 2004. Since its acquisition the feature set of Blogger has languished while new offerings such as WordPress.com have entered the scene.

Blogger and WordPress are both attractive options for those looking to set up a blog. These services eliminate the need to find a host and install blogging software. Because these are hosted services, you have less control than if you host your own blog. Both services differ in what they limit and to what degree.

WordPress.com is the free, hosted version of the popular content management system WordPress.org. WordPress is an excellent, feature-rich blogging platform. The full feature set of WordPress is only available if you install it with your own web host (the software itself is free). Many (if not most) professional blogs use Wordress as their content management system.

Here is an example of an old Blogger blog
Here is an example of a Beta Blogger blog
Here is an example of a WordPress.com blog

Both Blogger.com and WordPress.com are extremely straightforward to set-up and use. I think that Blogger is slightly more user-friendly than WordPress.com for the novice blogger, but 15-30 minutes of reading and tinkering with WordPress is all that is really needed to get going. Blogger.com is also a little more easily integrated into cell phone, camera phone, e-mail blogging, and the like, and is probably a slightly better choice for personal bogs and total beginners.

WordPress features include static pages, categories, an extremely powerful editor, and many other features. Pages are a way of keeping static HTML pages within the dynamic blogging interface. This can also be accomplished with Blogger, but it is a hack and not as useful. What I do in Blogger to create a page is make a post or (cannibalize an old post from months ago), and link to that post from a static part of my blog. Look at my age here for an example. The links in the navigation bar are all links to old bog posts which I then use as content management pages. This works, but it is a hack and not nearly as slick as WordPress’ built-in pages feature.

Blogger is more useful than WordPress.com if you like to tinker. WordPress.com limits the number of templates you can use and has a somewhat (but not fully) customizable sidebar. Blogger gives you complete control over your template. You have total access to the HTML and can basically do whatever you want. Any sort of add-on, template sidebar structure, navigation and the like are yours to tinker with. This is also possible if you use install WordPress on your own server, but the freely hosted WordPress.com currently does not allow access to the HTML.

The non-techie (or at least non-tinkerer) will not really care about this feature. WordPress.com’s templates are really superb, and I think that they tend to look much better out of the box than Blogger templates. You can however, tweak Blogger templates to look pretty much like WordPress templates–it just requires some technical knowledge.

The new Beta Blogger really changes things up. Blogger has lifted many features from WordPress.com while still allowing access to the HTML (coming soon). It is unclear right now whether the new Blogger will support multiple pages like WordPress, but the sidebar is now widgetized like WordPress and categories are supported (Blogger is calling them “labels”). You can drag and drop sidebar widgets quite easily (a huge improvement over the old Blogger). The publishing scheme has been reworked and changes/new posts appear instantaneously (no more spinning triangle of death). Here are some more features according to the Blogger team:

A lot of folks have been wanting to use new features like Labels but with their existing template. Or there are folks who are looking for more fine-grained control than offered with the new Layouts system.

Fortunately, it’s always been part of our plan to introduce a new Edit HTML system for Blogger in beta. This system will not only let folks have the degree of customizability they desire, but it will let you create templates that are customizable with the Layouts system. Right now we are finishing the first version of this system and will be introducing in the “days not weeks” timeframe.

I am anxiously awaiting the opportunity to move my blog over. Hopefully this will fix the rendering problems that my blog (and tons of other Blogger blogs) has in Internet Explorer and Firefox.

check out Jason Heath’s Bass Page for more information

Advertisements

August 19, 2006 - Posted by | Blogging, General, Uncategorized, Web 2.0

13 Comments »

  1. […] Read here for a nice introductory comparison of wordpress.com vs the and now newly improved Blogger emerging in beta. […]

    Pingback by Caffeinated Gonzo! » Wordpress vs Blogger Beta | August 20, 2006 | Reply

  2. Blogger also allows you to change URLs, allows you to use file transfer to have your blog appear on your site (instead of downloading and building like WordPress), and even in beta, you can still customize your template…

    Comment by StarLotus | August 24, 2006 | Reply

  3. oops…wrong url, sorry!!, and blogger also now has word verification to prevent spamming and botting from occuring…

    Comment by StarLotus | August 24, 2006 | Reply

  4. and costom templates!!!

    Comment by StarLotus | August 24, 2006 | Reply

  5. Agreed. I just checked out your blog, and your template looks very nice–clean and easy to read. I am using Blogger for my main blog and am playing around with WordPress features on this blog. I also started a Beta Blogger blog, and I am looking forward to moving my main blog to Beta Blogger. Being able to categorize comments and manipulate the sidebar as widget components are two things I really like about WordPress, and it looks like Blogger will now have those features as well.

    Comment by jsh177 | August 24, 2006 | Reply

  6. Its tempting to think that, against a new FREE MSN Spaces, a popular FREE wordpress.com service and the new FREE blogger that typepad at least, if not all of sixapart is rather fucked.

    Comment by Andrew | August 26, 2006 | Reply

  7. It is difficult to find a reson to use the paid Typepad service, isn’t it?

    Comment by jsh177 | August 26, 2006 | Reply

  8. Do give http://www.webmasterworld.com/community_building/3174608.htm a look.

    Also http://www.hedir.com/cafe/about18221.html which talks about blogger vs wordpress. Blogger is going to die soon.

    Thanks

    Comment by Augastin Francis | December 4, 2006 | Reply

  9. Hi Jason,

    Nice post comparing the two. I currently have Blogger, but exploring other options. Can you tell me whether in WordPress, it is possible to create drop-down lists that show post titles for a specific label/category? So, for example, a drop-down list for all titles with the category “Jazz,” or a drop-down list for all titles with the category “Tech” or “Linux”?

    Thanks.
    -Amit

    Comment by Amit | April 10, 2007 | Reply

  10. dob

    Comment by Larcik-om | January 19, 2008 | Reply

  11. Right this way, ma’am.

    Comment by JafSlamnbamn | February 24, 2008 | Reply

  12. eRHDLAHf8gjW0

    Comment by Efrain | January 7, 2009 | Reply

  13. purchase Cipro cheap

    Comment by Devon | January 22, 2009 | Reply


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

%d bloggers like this: